In January I went alone to St Thomas Mount in Chennai. I climbed the stone steps several times a day, stopping at each station of the cross, and I went down to the apostle’s tomb at Santhome.
I went alone because I wanted solitude. Loneliness came with it anyway. They are not the same thing, and the gap between them is what this reflection is about.
Two men helped me think it through. Both taught that the separate self is not the final truth about us. Alan Watts said it more brilliantly than anyone, and drank himself to an early death. Ram Dass said it less elegantly, and lived it through a stroke into old age. The difference between them is the difference between trying to escape loneliness and offering it up.
Watts and the bottle
Watts spent his working life telling people that the separate self is an illusion. In The Book he argued that the feeling of being an ego shut up inside a bag of skin is a hallucination, a convention we have mistaken for a fact.1 For many people in the West he was the first to say it at all, and he said it with wit and complete conviction.
He also drank heavily in his later years. Monica Furlong, his biographer, describes drinking fed by a loneliness he never resolved.2 He died in his sleep in November 1973, aged fifty-eight.
It is easy to call this hypocrisy, and I don’t think it was. Watts saw clearly. Seeing was not his problem. He saw as an observer, and the observer stayed on his own. Knowing that the self is not separate did nothing for the evenings.
William James noticed long ago that drink imitates mystical union. Sobriety, he wrote, “diminishes, discriminates, and says no”, while drunkenness “expands, unites, and says yes”.3 Jung went further. Writing to Bill Wilson, the co-founder of Alcoholics Anonymous, in 1961, he said the craving for alcohol was at bottom a thirst for wholeness, for union with God. He put it in three Latin words, spiritus contra spiritum: the Spirit set against the spirit in the bottle.4
Read with Jung, Watts was not a fraud who happened to drink. He knew non-duality as an idea, and he went looking for it as an experience through the one door that opened for him every night. The bottle gave him the yes. It could not give him anyone to say it to.
Ram Dass and the mill
Ram Dass came at the same truth from the other end. He had been a Harvard psychologist; he had taken more psychedelics than almost anyone; and he found in India that none of it had made him free. What he brought back from his guru, Neem Karoli Baba, was less a theory than a practice: take whatever turns up and offer it.
Grist for the Mill, put together with Stephen Levine from talks given between 1974 and 1976, takes its title from a miller’s phrase.5 Grist is the grain brought to be ground. Whatever is brought to the mill becomes flour, and nothing is wasted. Anxiety, desire, boredom, grief, loneliness: all of it is grain.
In a radio interview from the same years he described what this changed. The anxiety still came. The difference was that “instead of my being anxious, there is anxiety.”6 The feeling was no longer his property, so it no longer had to be defended against or drowned.
He was held to this. A stroke in 1997 left him partly paralysed and struggling for words. In Still Here he wrote about the stroke as grace, a fierce kind, and he meant it.7 The man who taught that everything is grist did not get to choose the grain.
This is where the two men part. Watts tried to dissolve the lonely self, and the dissolving had to be done again every evening. Ram Dass let the loneliness come and handed it over. He didn’t need to get out of it. He needed to bring it.
The Mount
Thomas is the right apostle for this. He is the one who was not there. When the risen Christ came to the disciples behind locked doors, Thomas was somewhere else, on his own, and he refused to believe on their word.8 Earlier it was Thomas who said, flatly, let us go too and die with him. He did nothing secondhand. Tradition holds that he brought the gospel to India, was killed near the Mount, and was buried at Mylapore, where Santhome Basilica now stands over his tomb.9
The beggar. A beggar asked me for money by holding his cupped hand in front of me. I was startled and stepped back. I gave him nothing. He put his hand on my head and blessed me anyway. I have thought about that hand more than anything else from the trip. Everything in me was set up for the usual exchange: I give, he receives, and the thanks runs from him to me. He turned it round. He gave from nothing, to someone who had given him nothing, and he did not wait to see whether I deserved it. It was grace in the plainest form I have met. For a moment with his hand on my head, I did not feel alone. I had come to India alone. I ate alone, slept alone and sat thoughtfully in the shrine church alone.
The Homeless Jesus. On the Mount there is a cast of Timothy Schmalz’s Homeless Jesus: a figure asleep on a bench under a blanket, recognisable only by the wounds in his feet.10 The Son of Man has nowhere to lay his head.11 Standing by it I saw the beggar again. The man who blessed me and the man on the bench were not two.
The tomb. At Santhome I went down to the tomb and cried. I hadn’t planned to. This was the man who wanted to put his hand in the wounds, who would not take anyone’s word for it, and who came all this way. His doubt was not distance from God. It was a demand to be close. I think I cried because I recognised it.
The steps. I climbed the stations several times each day. Up past Jesus falling, past Simon taking the cross, past the stripping and the taking down, to the top; then down, and up again. The repetition did what kirtan does. The prayers wore smooth, and the self that was saying them wore smooth with them. After a few climbs I was no longer making the stations. The stations were being made. Ram Dass would have recognised it: not my climbing, but climbing. Every ascent was grist.
Not two, and not alone
I came home thinking that loneliness is not the opposite of union. It is often where union is first noticed.
Watts was right that the separate self is not the last word about us. Where he went wrong, and where a great many of us go wrong, was in trying to get out of loneliness by dissolving: into drink, into ideas, into work, into other people. Dissolving has to be repeated, because whoever wakes up the next morning is still on their own.
The beggar’s hand did not dissolve me. It met me. Thomas did not lose himself in the group behind the locked doors; he asked to touch. Non-duality, as I understand it, is not the disappearance of the one who is lonely. It is the discovery that God was never on the other side of the loneliness. God was in it.
Ram Dass would say: bring the loneliness to the mill. I would add: carry it up the steps, take it down to the tomb, and let a stranger with nothing put his hand on it. It will be ground. What comes out is not the end of being one person. It is being one person who is no longer alone.
Related reading: Book review: It’s Here Now (Are You?) by Bhagavan Das and Ramanuja and Advaita: how devotion fits a non-dual philosophy.
Notes
- Alan Watts, The Book: On the Taboo Against Knowing Who You Are (New York: Pantheon, 1966), ch. 1.
- Monica Furlong, Zen Effects: The Life of Alan Watts (Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1986); see especially the final chapter, “The Home Behind Home, 1969–1973”.
- William James, The Varieties of Religious Experience: A Study in Human Nature (London: Longmans, Green, 1902), Lectures XVI–XVII, “Mysticism”.
- C. G. Jung to William G. Wilson, 30 January 1961, in C. G. Jung, Letters, vol. 2: 1951–1961, ed. Gerhard Adler and Aniela Jaffé (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1975).
- Ram Dass and Stephen Levine, Grist for the Mill (Santa Cruz: Unity Press, 1976); revised edition, Grist for the Mill: Awakening to Oneness (New York: HarperOne, 2014).
- Ram Dass, radio interview, mid-1970s, released as an episode of Ram Dass Here and Now (Be Here Now Network), beherenownetwork.com/?p=1848.
- Ram Dass, Still Here: Embracing Aging, Changing, and Dying (New York: Riverhead, 2000).
- John 20:24–29; for “let us also go, that we may die with him”, John 11:16.
- Stephen Neill, A History of Christianity in India: The Beginnings to AD 1707 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984), ch. 2.
- “Homeless Jesus finds a new home at the Vatican”, The Catholic Register, catholicregister.org, reporting the cast installed on St Thomas Mount on Palm Sunday.
- Matthew 8:20; see also Matthew 25:35–40, the passage Schmalz names as the sculpture’s source.
Leave a Reply