The Feather and the Mirror

From presence to transmission

Artificial intelligence has not broken the Church’s way of communicating. It has shown us what that way had already become.

The Church took to the media early and with real hope. In 1963 the Second Vatican Council issued Inter mirifica, named for its opening words about the “wonderful” inventions of the press, cinema, radio and television, and urged Catholics to use them for the Gospel. Televised Masses followed, then diocesan websites, communications offices and social media accounts. In 2020 the livestream became, for months, the only way most Catholics could “attend” Mass at all. Since then we have had Zoom retreats, online spiritual direction, and short video reflections from priests, promoted on diocesan feeds.

Each step made sense on its own, and some of it has been a lifeline for the housebound, the sick and the dying. But taken together, these steps taught the Church to treat the transmission of religious content as if it were pastoral presence. Warmth on a screen came to stand in for a person in the room.

The feather

I have spent much of this year with Jeff Noon’s novel Vurt, and wrote a paper reading it through Augustine. In Noon’s alternate Manchester, people slip into a shared dreamworld by putting coloured feathers in their mouths. Once used, a feather turns cream and is worthless, a property the makers build in so that users come back for more. The dream is designed from the start to produce dependence.

Now and then a dreamer is overtaken by what Noon calls the Haunting: “the real world calling you home.” Nothing in the dream has changed. The dreamer simply knows it is a dream, and that another life exists beyond it. The culture of the Vurt treats this as a failure of nerve. Its resident guide, tells the Haunted not to withdraw but to go higher, into feathers within feathers that never leave the dream.

My argument was that the desire behind the feathers is real, and that Augustine would recognise it as the restless heart. Intensity does not satisfy it. A made world is not evil, and it becomes counterfeit only when it is mistaken for home. A short video reflection on a phone is a very mild feather. It is warm, quick and pleasant, and once it has been watched it turns cream. The question is not whether such things are allowed. It is whether the Church has started to take them for home.

The mirror

Artificial intelligence can now produce, in seconds, a warm and well-structured reflection on any Gospel passage, in the style of any person whose videos it has seen. This is the uncomfortable part. If a machine can generate the reflection, then the reflection never needed a person behind it. The content was already detachable from presence. AI does not empty pastoral communication. It shows how much of it was empty already, by doing it just as well with nobody there.

In another paper I have argued that AI is best understood as human reason technologically extended: mediation, not presence. It carries thought without thinking, and it cannot take the place of the encounters with God and neighbour that all mediation is meant to serve. The Church spent sixty years producing that kind of extended human speech at scale and often calling it ministry. AI makes the category visible because it is that category with the human taken out.

Pope Leo’s caution about AI in Magnifica humanitas is right. But it comes from inside the trajectory it cautions against. The real question is not whether AI should be used for pastoral content. It is whether we had already let content replace the presence it was supposed to point to.

Near the end of Vurt, Noon turns to his reader: “Maybe you’re reading it now. Or maybe you’re playing the feather. Or maybe you’re in the feather, thinking that you’re reading the novel, with no way of knowing.” I should say the same about this post. I use AI in my own work, for editing and for checking sources. Maybe you are reading something I wrote. Maybe you are reading something a machine assembled. If you cannot tell the difference, that is my point.

Noise and silence

In a later novel, Falling Out of Cars (2002), Noon imagines a world struck by an illness in which people can no longer process the information that reaches them. They overdose on reality. Signs are simplified as far as they will go, mirrors are dangerous to look into, and everyone takes a daily drug just to keep the noise at bay. It reads now less like science fiction than a description of where we are heading.

In a world where the line between the real and the performed grows more blurred every year, we will not reach people with ever more information, more content or more polished theological and scriptural reflections. It is in the places where everything is stripped back and purged that people will find their rest.

Much of my own journey has been in silence. I think of the long hours of mouna, held silence, at the Mandala ashram. I have eaten lentils for Easter Sunday lunch sitting on the floor of the ashram dining room. The rhythm of the hours of the ashram day from the ringing of a handbell outside the windows of the sleeping quarters to the long silence of the night is punctuated at times. A reading of a text or singing of kirtan. Yet in satsang the silence is held. We sing to the divine without speaking to each other.

The ashram has used technology too, with online satsang and recorded meditation, but it seems to have held its space better. A recorded meditation is no use unless you sit down and do it. The medium points you back to the practice and cannot stand in for it. The ashram is where I go to let myself be unmade.

What cannot be generated

Some things cannot be produced by any machine: Mass said in a cold church on a weekday morning; confession; the sick visited in their own beds; a priest standing beside someone in intensive care, saying nothing, for as long as it takes; bread put into a hungry person’s hands. None of it scales, and none of it can be broadcast without becoming something else.

The disciples on the road to Emmaus had the Scriptures explained to them by Christ himself, and still did not know him. “He was known of them in breaking of bread” (Luke 24:35). Explanation did not open their eyes. Presence did.

I see the same thing on the ward. Patients do not remember the leaflet or the video. They remember the person who was there.

In Vurt, the narrator finally refuses to let his sister stay in the beautiful dream. “This isn’t the real world,” he tells her. “The real world is not beautiful, but it’s where you belong.” Perhaps AI is the Church’s Haunting: the moment the dream gives itself away, and the real world calls us home. That would make it a gift, though not the kind we were expecting.

Follow new essays by email

Leave a Reply