What if AI causes content inflation?
Inflation happens when too much currency is chasing too little of anything worth having. Each note buys less than it did the day before. For the whole of the digital age, words, images and video have worked as a kind of currency. They bought attention, and attention bought status, income and influence. That arrangement depended on content being costly to make. It took time, skill or nerve. AI removes the cost. An essay takes seconds. So does a portrait, a song, a film clip or a voice. When anyone can print the currency at will, it stops buying anything.
Everyone is famous
Fame is a ratio: a few people watched by many. Social media had already bent that ratio by giving everyone a platform and a following. AI finishes the job. When every person can produce polished output without limit and every feed is full of it, fame is spread so evenly that it means nothing. Influencers become so common that they have no meaningful influence. An influencer among millions of influencers is one person talking in a crowd where everyone else is talking too.
Back to the material
In a world saturated with images and media, I think people will retreat to their material nativity: the physical world they were born into, the body, the room, the street, the people within reach. When any image can be made by anyone, and nothing on a screen can be trusted to have happened, value moves to what cannot be generated. A meal that somebody cooked. A face across a table. A voice in the same room.
This is not nostalgia. It is what people do when a currency fails. They go back to things that hold their worth.
Gradually and then suddenly
If this is right, the illusion collapses only about a quarter of a century after the digital age reached into every part of our lives. How did this happen? In Hemingway’s The Sun Also Rises, a man is asked how he went bankrupt. “Gradually and then suddenly,” he says.
The gradual part has been going on for years. Every blog, every feed, every upload added a little more to the supply, and each addition made the rest worth slightly less. Nobody noticed much, because it still seemed to matter who had written what, and whether it was any good. The sudden part is the arrival of machines that produce content faster than anyone could ever read, watch or hear it.
Hyperinflation
I believe we are standing on the brink of the point at which content inflation becomes hyperinflation. In Germany in 1923, banknotes lost their value so quickly that people papered their walls with them and burned them in the stove, because the paper was worth more as fuel than as money. Children played with bundles of notes in the street.
That is where digital content is heading. First we paper the walls with it. Then we light fires with it. Eventually we stop bothering to do even that, and treat it as litter.
This website, and these words I am writing now, are nothing more than tomorrow’s junk.
Leave a Reply